Like others have said RENT A CAR!
First of all we had a great experience at this resort. It is a good, solid 3 star resort, however the staff is 5 star. We have been around the world and Oyster Bay has the most exceptional staff we have encountered.
The maid service was excellent. Although we had to ask for extra towels nearly every day (because there are two people in the rooms two towels is not enough) the maids were on top of it. They even did our breakfast dishes!
I have to say what stood out the most is the maintenance man who came to our room. There was an outlet box with no outlet in it on our balcony and I called for en extension cord. The maintenance man came to bring it and when I explained why I needed it (kindle was dying at the end of my book) he asked if I would mind him coming back to put the outlet in. We said sure, thinking he would do it another time, and he came back and wired the outlet, put WD-40 on the slider because he had noticed it stuck and changed a lightbulb....what! Someone who actually does their job! It was almost 5 when he came and he stayed past that. It was surprising---I would hire him!
The huge down side was that our room faced the harbor and they were doing very loud construction on the pier. At 8 a.m every morning the beeping and pounding started and didn't let up until 5. That was not good for us as we like to sit outside on the balcony.
All in all, we would stay here again. We usually prefer more of a four or five star resort but the location of this resort was great. I gave three stars because they needed another pool. We prefer a quiet pool where we can read and listen to the ocean. Unfortunately, a loud younger couple decided to get their country music on and brought a radio, and rafts to the pool----definitely not four star behavior---they were looking for a party pool and the people there clearly wanted the quiet. If there was a party pool for the youngsters maybe that might solve this type of problem and elevate the resort to more of a 4.
I have to say again, the staff was great. They were truly representative of The Friendly Island!