We stayed at the Oddfellows for an evening earlier this year, it was outstanding. The decor is quirky and general atmosphere is great. We were greated by a really helpful member of staff who booked us in promptly and showed us to our room (Newbrook Loft)
The rooms were stunning and we didn't want to leave, the bar downstairs was really busy but again the staff were really helpful.... and make the best mojitos in the world!!
It was one of the best hotels we have ever stayed in, cannot recommend it enough!