We stayed at the Membly Hall Hotel in November 2011 on a 'Just Go' coach holiday.
We had read mixed reviews about the hotel but most were positive. We find that you have to 'read between the lines' and make your own decision. (incidentally, why can't those writing the most critical reviews spell?)
The hotel is a charming little family run establishment, the place was clean and tidy, the staff were pleasant and the meals were good. Our stay there, bearing in mind we were part of a coach tour, was great value too.
Our room, room 31, did not look like an hotel room at all, with it's exposed roofing joists it was more reminscent of the bedroom in a holiday cottage.More