We stayed 6 days at the Old Turner Inn and it was wonderful. The location is an easy walk from the ferry dock and they are centrally located so easy walking to restaurants and island amenities.
Kathleen and Krista were wonderful and they went out of their way to make us feel comfortable and welcome. The rooms are all nice and the real fireplaces in each room are a nice touch. They provided the easy to light wood and we had a romantic fire going every evening. The breakfast each morning was first class. We will absolutely rebook with them when we revisit Catalina!