There are LOTS of choices on Caye Caulker, but my wife and I stayed a full week at Da Real Macaw because the location is perfect, i.e. in the middle of everything-- you can sit on the porch and watch the 14-hour a day parade of interesting folks coming and going on Front Street. However, you can also retreat to your room for quiet and privacy.
Obviously, we love people watching... if you do too, be sure to stay at least a couple days here. If they are on the Caye, you'll see them.
PS-- Buy the Banana Bread from the strolling salesman. It rocks.
- Free Wifi