After lots of research, I booked a private snorkel tour with Star Tours to avoid a large group and have a quiet experience. Just as we were walking on to the boat we were told that we were going with a group and that the boat for the private was "broken". We ended up in a group with two toddlers, one of which was extremely enoying.
It was actually quite a bit more difficult to try to get to Cay Caulker by water taxi and if we hadn't caught the first one (made it by about one minute by getting the first tender from our ship and rushing) we would have missed the tour! The walk through town to the water taxi is not recomended.
Also, we ended up not going to Shark and Ray alley but a similar place so never actually saw that. I guess the "private boat " might have been actually broken but I would not recomend this tour at all.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.