Reliable is a good way to describe this popular restaurant on Nantucket. Brotherhood of Thieves has been around for ten or more years now and has remained popular as a somewhat moderately priced place for simple dining. The burgers are quite good and are accompanied by curly fries and all the fixings. The chowder and lobster bisque are wonderful and the compliment of salads and other offerings are typical of island fare.
On my last visit I had the opportunity to dine upstairs for the first time and liked the difference in decor. Soft greens and blues and more intimate dining spaces are quite inviting and in sharp contrast to the dark wood and pub atmosphere of the first floor.
On an island where a $38 entree is commonplace, Brotherhood of Thieves is a less expensive option for those who want good food and good service without a lot of fuss. I highly recommend the place. Be prepared to wait for a table at this popular place. They'll give you a hand held buzzer that will vibrate when your table is ready. Meanwhile, you can shop up and down Broad Street while you wait.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.