We were very happy with our stay at Hotel Vestibul Palace. It is located right in the walls of Diocletian's historic palace. You couldn't ask for a better location. Fortunately, because I planned our trip so far in advance, we had no trouble staying in the main location. Having read the reviews of travelers who stayed in the Annex, I was careful to insure that we stayed in the "Palace" section. Interestingly, this is the second hotel we've stayed in on this particular trip where we were "upgraded" to a "superior suite" -- in fact, a "loft" arrangement -- in which our bed was up a flight of stairs from the main part of the suite. Although this is architecturally attractive design, and I'm sure looks great in travel magazine photographs, I would generally prefer having the bed on the same level as the bathroom for those late night-time visits one must make. Nevertheless, the staff did ask me if this was OK with us. I accepted it, and so I have no complaints at this point.
Overall, we very much enjoyed our two-night stay, due to the extremely comfortable bed, the almost luxurious bathroom, and the spacious, living-room like space we were afforded. We have no complaints about the service, which was unusually accommodating, friendly and courteous. The breakfast buffet was actually better than one usually encounters in hotels of this type -- the friendly staff actually explained what was available, offered to prepare cooked eggs for us, and then whipped me up a superb omelet to order, both mornings.
In conclusion, if this beautiful hotel isn't worth 5 stars, what is?