Your options for food are extremely limited in Alexandrea Bay, NY. Which surprises me, in such a tourist area where do the people actually eat. Coleman's Dock of the Bay, doesn't have to do much and hasn't done anything to update themselves in over thirty years. The reason they don't have to do anything in quality or presentation is because they are the only spot directly on the Bay, where you can pull your boat up and park to have a few drinks. It's more a hang out get some beers and bar food. They claim to also be a full on Smoke House. But honestly the smoker gives off a smell of Cow Terds. They should stick to perfecting basics and switch to a better smelling wood for cooking. I don't know why you are serving a New England Lobster style Lobster Seafood Roll. How fresh can this be. How fresh can it be wen every lobster piece looks like a machine cut Lego . The salads need some sprucing up. Give me more then a bag of lettuce and 4 pieces of chicken. I've ordered the salad to be healthy not cheated. Fresh food shouldn't take long to make. But when your defrosting and not cooking that's what happens.
If your going to check this place out or any place in this area. Just realize it's going to be basic and a strange combination of weird NY Upstate non-cultural options. Every place serves Nachos ! Mixed in with some Canadian influences. If your Heath conscious your gonna be disappointed. Plus the entire night life closes up at 8pm. River community my arrse.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.