My boyfriend and I spent 3 nights at Gerald's a few months ago. We we happy with it. The owner is friendly and is pet deer is pretty cute. It was also nice to have breakfast with hummingbirds feeding close by. The room was great and clean and the place was super quiet. We enjoyed the pool on the roof and it felt as if it was our private pool as we were always the only ones up there.
The restaurant of the hotel is THE place to eat on the island. It was always busy at meal times. The food is excellent. We tried lots of things on the menu.. our favorite definitely being the bratwursts and the pizza. Oh and if you want a great drink try the Gerald's special!More