My lovely wife and I visited Cosmopolitan on a Tuesday night at 5:00 PM after visiting an art exhibition just a block away. The restaurant is located just across the street from Allentown's Symphony Hall and a block away from its Museum of Art. The restaurant building is a restored 5 story stone structure that is beautiful to look at, especially compared to other buildings on the block, including a vacant hi-rise hotel across the street. But don't let that deter you from visiting the restaurant. It has free valet parking and numerous parking lots and garages in the neighborhood. Upon entering the front door, you are in a completely different world. The terms chic and glamorous come to mind, a look and atmosphere conspicuously absent from the world of fine dining in the Lehigh Valley for far too many years. The dining area and adjacent bar area are tastefully decorated including a hugh crystal chandelier hanging in an opening to the second floor. There is a wide winding stairway to the upper floors, as well as an elevator. These floors contain an overflow dining room on the second floor, banquet areas, and a soon to be open bar/club on the top floor. Considering our visit was on a Tuesday night during the last week of August, and we were dining early, the first floor dining area filled up rather nicely. We were given two menus by the hostess. One containing items from the former occupant of the space, Sal's Spagetti House, and the other containing Cosmopolitan's own offerings. The Sal's menu is a Tuesday night special, including an $11.95 plate of Sal's spagetti and meatballs or sausage. We were so intrigued by this unusual nod to the prior occupant of the building that we ordered just a side order of meatballs and sausage as a "pre-appetizer". Good move on our part. The meatballs and sausage were absolutely delicious, and the sauce a deep, rich, obviously slow cooked tomato delight. We were so taken by our very favorable reaction, that we ordered an additional 10 meatballs to take home with us.
Our main meal was equally as impressive. The menu contains a nice assortment of fish (scallops, salmon), meat (filet, braised short ribs, pork chop), and poultry (chicken, duck) and some other more unusual items. Our server, Amy, was excellent, both pleasant and professional, and was able to answer all of our questions regarding the building, history of the restaurant and menu items. To start, we ordered the onion soup and beet salad. The soup was one of the best I have recently had, with a dark, rich broth with deep flavors of red wine and beef broth, with just the right amount of melted cheese and a welcome absence of saltiness. My wife's salad was fresh and well dressed with vinaigrette, with both red and golden beets and gorgonzola cheese. My main course was the braised short ribs with carrots, asparagus , mashed potatoes and a delicious sauce reduction. The flavor was excellent and the meat pulled apart with a fork, although it was a little fatty. My wife had the salmon with gnocchi and green pea puree. The entire dish was first class. For dessert, we shared a slice of "Hess's" traditional strawberry pie, which was actually big enough to feed 4 people. It was just as we remembered from Hess's Patio restaurant (in the former department store, for those not from the Lehigh Valley).
All in all, a wonderful experience for our first, but not last, visit to this restaurant. This could be a special occasion restaurant, but also one that should be visited on a regular basis. While the prices are higher than most people in Allentown may be used to paying, the quality of the ingredients and the food preparation make it a great value. Frankly, there are not yet that many good reasons to visit downtown Allentown. Hopefully, that will change with the completion of the nearby new hockey arena complex and associated businesses. But, luckily for local residents, the Cosmopolitan is way ahead of the redevelopment curve and should be supported by those interested in a fine dining experience in a first class restaurant. Fine dining? In Allentown? Yes, there is.