We read great reviews about Islamorada we had to try it out. When we first walked in we were kind of met by the I guess you can call it Hostess. She was an older women and I only say that because I wanted to describe her since I did not see her name. When we walked in she starred at us then looked down at the seating chart and started having a conversation with a waitress called Anna. She seemed fixed to make sure we were seated at 32 at least that's what I was gathering, Since this women was cold and not very inviting. She was not the nicest to Anna either, who was told to tell Erica to take care of our table. Now the visit stars getting a bit better. Anna seated us and said our waitress would be right with us. About 5 minutes later she stopped back by the table to ask if Erica had stopped by to help us. We said no, but asked her if she could be our waitress since she had been so nice so far. She agreed. We had a fantastic meal, my wife had the grilled Salmon and I had the Catfish. Anna, was an awesome waitress and made sure we were well taken care of. By the way Erica never did show up at the table. After dinner we paid and as we were leaving the older lady was right there and we smiled at her showing our pleasure with the whole meal but she totally ignored us did not even wish us a nice day as we left. She stared directly at us so I know she knew we were there, but there was nothing but a chill coming from her. Besides the Hostess that evening, everything was awesome.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.