We order three pizzas to be picked up in 45 minutes (a little before the time we wanted to eat). Old Forge Pizza was at most a 5 minute drive from our condo. We should have been suspicious about the pizza as it was ready within a minute of our arrival. When we got back home it became obvious they had not waited to cook our pizza but must have done it as soon as we hung up and then tried to keep it warm. We relayed our story to a "local" who said he had not heard any great things about Old Forge.
If you really want a pizza I suggest you buy one in the grocery store and cook it yourself.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.