I have been to The Cody Inn numerous times in the last several years and loved its quaint charm and delicious food, particularly the weiner schnitzel. I discovered that the restaurant was no longer owned by George, but decided to give it a try anyway in November 2009. We ordered mussels that tasted like pencil erasers and smelled so horrid we asked that they be removed from the table. We ordered the rack of lamb, which had also been a favorite of mine before, but this time it was bland and tasteless. My brother ordered the weiner schnitzel and claimed it was grizzly. My sister ordered the fish and stated that it was both fishy and mealy. The steaks were so oversauced it was difficult to taste the quality of the beef. I truly loved this place when George owned it and it was always on my list of places to go in Colorado. The new owner hovered over a nearby table for at least 15 minutes while we waited for our dinners. Perhaps he should have been in the kitchen supervising. I'd rather eat at Denny's.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.