We own vacation property in Fernandina and have eaten at most of the restaurants in town. I had heard about Don Quixote's, but had not checked it out. My confusion was it is basically the same building at Pepper's, a Mexican restaurant (same owners I found out). It is technically next door, but unless you're looking specifically for it, it is easy to miss. I checked out the menu during the day while walking, and it looked great, so we went on a Sat. evening. The menu is extensive with large entrees, as well as a tapas menu. Very good and diverse selection of food. I ordered the Paella, which was very good. My husband ordered a scallop tapa, along with a beef one, both of which were excellent. Nice wine selection, we had wonderful service, and a very nice atmosphere. White table cloth, upscale; we will definately be back.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.