We stopped in to Baxter's for a quick dinner during our stay on Amelia. We should have listened to our instincts when we noticed all the "Best of..." plaques in the entryway. Not usually a good signal!
We thought that Baxter's had terrifically friendly and nice servers. Unfortunately the decor is dark and dated. And the food, despite the awards for best steaks/beef, was mediocre at best.
There are many better options on Amelia.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.