Having read the reviews we decided to try out Upper Crust Pizza and were not disappointed. We had meatballs & spaghetti for appetisers followed by Pizza for mains and shared a slice of Homemade Coconut Cheesecake for afters. The food was divine, service was speedy and personable, the Restuarant was spotless. I'm not sure how anyone could fault this Restuarant - we've been on the Keys for 2 weeks and can honestly say this is without a doubt the BEST Restuarant we've eaten in and trust me we've eaten in way too many ;-) The food is undoubtably cooked fresh to order and worth the wait - it makes such a pleasant change not to have your food handed to you 2mins after you've ordered it like so many other places. Starters & mains were piping hot - another delightful change :-) We even ordered an extra slice of coconut cheesecake to take home as it was scrumptious :-) This is the first review I've written on Trip Advisor and having read some of the negative reviews I felt it was important to do this... You only have to read the owners replies to the negative reviews to know that this family truly aim to provide Great Quality Food & Service & we're happy to Commend them for it as I'm sure lots more people will do.. Thanks a mill :-)
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.