Sea Critters is our go to place when we start our SPB vacations - for us it epitomises our SPB experience - wonderful location on the water, good food and service and a lovely casual friendly atmosphere - instant relaxation!
We dined here several times during our 2 week stay and were not disappointed at any time. The sea food broil is not only plentiful and great quality but also excellent value in my opinion. Also, they are extremely accommodating - my husband has a severe clam allergy (clams are included in the broil) and our inquiry to find out if it was possible to not only have them excluded from his broil but to also have his broil cooked in a cleaned pan as just the water is enough to give him a problem, was met without fuss - our waiter checked with the kitchen and they said no problem. It was delicious and my husband was fine.
The service is always friendly, if the seating area you want isn't free ( we always love to sit on the dock tables) have a drink at the bar while you wait - the bartenders mix an excellent vodka martini and they are famous for their margaritas.
My husband also recommends the ribs, and I also love the scallop risotto and the fresh grouper never disappoints.
Fine dining it isn't - but it doesn't pretend to be - but if you like a beautiful location, good food, friendly staff and a busy casual atmosphere you won't be disappointed.
Looking forward to being back at Christmas!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.