We visited the Old Tavernier based on a recommendation for our innkeeper. We arrived on the earlier side, around 5:15 and had no trouble getting a table, we chose to sit on the outside porch overlooking the dock area. Our waitress, Mary, was very friendly, informative and provided excellent service. I had the Greek salad (delicious) and fish of the day, along with a bottled beer. Wife had one of the specials, a shrimp, chicken and pasta in white garlic sauce. Both meals were well prepared, and wife's meal was a large portion, which she graciously passed over for me to finish :)
My meal was delicious, although the grilled fish portion was on the smaller side, but very tasty. We finished up with a piece of yummy key lime pie. Service was outstanding, food quality was very good,
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.