After dining out at a different restaurant each night to celebrate no kids for a week, Buffalo Gal was a no brainer. In fact, we almost put it on our list for two of the nights. To sum it all up, we have decided that this establishment is The Best Food a person can get up in the McCall, Donnelly, Tamarack, Cascade, New Meadows area hands down!
Let me tell you that this is a no frills appearance type of place which is right up our alley. We come here for the excellent food. The owners and staff are always pleasant and welcoming. I would recommend reservations if you come during summertime.
During this visit we enjoyed polenta fries, sweet onion soup, smoked Chinese ribs small plate. Hint: always try something of the chef' specials the day you visit. You will not be disappointed. We also enjoyed the shoulder steak with compound butter with herbs mixed into it , a twice baked potato and a ramekin with broccoli, peppers and Parmesan crust on top. I ordered the steak with sherries mushrooms. All I can say is that the food is just five star excellent! Steak was cooked to perfection and spiced nicely and that butter just sent it all over the top. We gave our compliments to the chef when he popped out and he was very receptive, appreciative and humble about it. He suggested that next time we try the brisket. I will! We will be back in the middle of July when my mother visits. She has said this is a must!
Oh, for dessert, I had the coconut ice cream with caramel sauce and hubby had the chocolate ice cream. Both served in a mini waffle cup. Everything is made here from scratch and you can tell. Divine, divine, divine!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.