I happened to find this place in a Google search and I am so glad I did. The cottages are beautiful, especially Captain's Quarters. There is plenty of privacy and it is positioned right on the beach with wonderful views of the mountains across the bay. The owner, Mary Lou is extremely accommodating and a wonderful person in general. There are also plenty of good hiking trails in the immediate vicinity that Mary Lou will be happy to tell you about as she and her husband are part of the team that keeps them up.
You will be very happy if stay at Captain Cook Bed and Breakfast. Trust me.