Just six weeks after our initial visit, my daughter and I enjoyed another terrific dinner at York Street. We both had the Flippin' Shrimp app, which are five medium sautéed shrimp served with a bacon maple cream sauce. My entree was one of the night's specials: Three Cheese Manicotti with Smokey Tomato Sauce. The blend of favors was light, unique and flavorful. Daughter enjoyed her Asian-Spiced Baby Back Ribs, served with garlic potatoes and steamed broccoli.
Since the Cafe has no signature drink (I wish they did!) I asked for a particular combination of juices and alcohol. It came exactly as requested and was delicious. Our only other food item was a chocolate hazelnut flourless torte, which daughter said was very tasteful, rich and delicious.
We must cite the work of Chris, our server. He is knowledgable, efficient, and utterly charming. His voice is smooth as the pie he serves and he could be a model for television announcers. He actually makes you feel like you've been friends all your life, and is sincerely grateful for your choosing to dine at The Cafe.
Dinner for two with apps, drinks, and one dessert - including dessert and tax, was $82. Given the exceptional service and outstanding food, we left $100 for the bill and tip, along with our words of appreciation.
This is a very popular restaurant (see ranking above) and they only take reservations for tables of 6 or more. So for dinner either go early or after 7:30 to be sure to get a table right away.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.