We were disappointed. We sought out this place because of Yankee Magazine's rating, but we were disappointed with the quantity for the price. There was nothing special about the lobster roll; it tasted good, the roll was fresh, but it was not different from any other lobster roll that we've tasted in Maine. However, the cost for a jumbo lobster roll was 4 dollars more for one that included just an extra claw on top. We got the smoked salmon spread with crackers, and paid more than it was worth. There was an assortment of crackers, with 6 of the 8 packages broken and crumbled. We had to ask for unbroken crackers - why would you give broken crackers with a spread? Anyway, we did like the spread, only to find out it was from Maine-ly Smoked Salmon, just down the road in Perry. Fortunately we bought some of the real spread. It seemed to us after we tasted the spread we bought at Maine-ly Smoked that the small appetizer potion sold at Quoddy bay Lobster had extra mayo or something added to it so it was less thick. We won't go back.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.