We have been vacationing in Wells Beach for the past 20 years and avoided this place for the past 10 years or so....for no particular reason.
Wanting something "new" we haven't tried in a while, we stopped by this "other" Billy's (vs the more well known Billy's in Perkins Cove)
I must admit, we went in with low expectations, but we left very impressed.
The chowders, both fish and clam, were quite excellent. It's not the thick, clam juice-ish type you get at Legal Seafood, but a brothy, creamy soup was refreshing. The rest of the dinner (steamed lobster) was reasonable, if not watery. The service was friendly and efficient.
The only direct comparison vs the Billy's in Ogunquit I can make is the rum punch--No comparison. Billy's in Ogunquit wins by a mile.