Have been to the Impudent Oyster many times, the food is always good. A group of 13 of us went recently for a family dinner, they could not accommodate us at one table, so we were seated as 7 at one table and 6 at another, which was totally fine. When we arrived, we went to the front door, it was locked, the gal that opened the door said "The winter entrance is over on the side, that is why the door was locked". Hmmmm, should there not be a sign right in front of the door then? We were not the only ones- the rest of the night, people were coming in through that door. The gal seemed somewhat annoyed, not sure why? If they want people to use the side door, put a BIG sign in front on the main door that everyone uses all summer.
Only one problem that I would address is that our other table, 2 of the people wanted burgers. The server told my Dad that he could have it- when my sister came to the table 5 mins later, she wanted a salald and burger, she was told she could not have a burger, as that was off of the childs menu and she had made one exception already and could not do it again. Huh?? Not sure how/why she could do that? Some in the group were annoyed about that.
The food overall is amazing. I had the beef short ribs and the were so good! Our server was also very knowledgable about gluten free, which is always a big plus for me. We had several kids at our table too, and she was really kind to all of them! :)
I will go back and I highly recommend, but not sure if the rest of the folks in my group would say the same thing.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.