The place is a high volume Mexican Restaurant / Sports Bar / Family Dining venue with a shark themed gift shop attached. there are actually several of them on the island, we elected the one just outside Edgartown.
The food really missed the mark. I am not sure they ever saw a jalapeno.. serious no lie. (I really have to learn to spell though). The salsa was weak no other way to describe it ... thought maybe it was an off night or something. When we approached one of the many Sharky's Cantina people flying around our table to inquire about the strength of their food ... we were politely told that their place featured what is both best and worst of America ... which we took to mean yeah I know it pretends to be Mexican Food but you cannot have everything in this place.
The portions were huge but again no Mexican fire ... I was hoping to find some fresh fish served Mexican Style ... no such luck. It was the typical Mexican - American entrees burritos, chimichangas, fajita etc etc.
I did not care for the food and although quite a nice large space ... did not appreciate the pace of service coupled with the booming voice our service staff was forced to communicate to us in ... I do not want to misrepresent all the Sharkey's on the island but this one really was not within expectations.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.