If you remember the delicious fish tacos at the former Finbar's in Orleans, weep no more for they are available at The Old Jailhouse Tavern. Yes, they are still fabulous. Nice menu, attentive new owner and staff. It was not busy when we arrived since it is a bit early for the tourists and it was a weeknight. This was our first time since it has been renovated and has a new owner, the former Finbar owners. Great to have a nice restaurant like this with a very nice menu to add to our Cape Cod list of places to eat when the towns fill with tourists and there are long waits at the best places. I am going back for the clam chowder which is something I use to judge all restaurants in beach areas. If they can't make good clam chowder in an area surrounded by fresh clams, there is something wrong with the place. It is embarrassing that the best clam/fish chowder I have had consistently is served at It's Nutts near Lambertville, NJ. Give this place a try, you won't be sorry.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.