The Mayflower Cafe is an old standby in this beautiful town. We live here but have not eaten here in years; thankfully, we were not disappointed. We were seated immediately in this slightly funky restaurant and were welcomed by friendly staff. I ordered the fish casserole of scallops, whitefish and shrimp with a Ritz cracker stuffing; my partner ordered the Portuguese fish and chips. Both were fabulous. The scallops were outstanding; and the Ritz cracker stuffing was out of this world. My partner's fish and chips were crispy, fresh and wonderful. This is probably the least expensive (decent) restaurant in Provincetown. There is little ambiance, other than listening to and watching the chefs at work. Bottom line: The Mayflower Cafe is a perfect place for a decent meal with great service at an excellent price. Not the place for a romantic evening, but perfect for most any other time.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.