When reading the reviews for Butch's, I couldn't figure out why they varied so much between solid 5's and 2's. When we finally had a date night without the kids, we decided to give Butch's a try. Our table was wobbly, the host brought a shim. If you know you have a problem, fix it before you seat customers. The table next to us had a knowledgable, attentive waitress who made good recommendations and they appeared to have a great meal. We had a checked-out waiter who didn't recommend anything. We thought we'd take the tapas approach to the evening. The lobster quesadilla was extremely disappointing. It was greasy and strangely prepared in a fried corn torilla, the crab cakes were mushy and flavorless - except for the exceptionally spicy chips on top (would have really appreciated a warning), and the goat cheese was good, but its the sort of thing you can get almost anywhere. It was served with 6 tiny baguette slices and apple slices. We asked for more bread, twice. We mentioned that the lobster wasn't up to par, the chef apologized and offered something else. We tried the salmon. Also disappointing. At that point, we gave up on the restaurant and went elsewhere to finish the evening. I can't say I'd ever go back. There are many better places to eat in the area.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.