We hear Soulshine was the best from one local, Millers from another, Sal & Mookies from another, and thought we would try them all and compare. Soulshine has a great atmosphere, nice wait staff, and a varied selection of pizzas. We tried the cheeseburger pizza and the barbeque chicken. Neither would be considered 'gourmet'. The cheeseburger had way too much mustard and was a bit dry. The barbeque chicken had to be eaten with a knife and fork due to the size of the chicken pieces - which was a combo of breast and thigh meat. There were no ingredients around the outer 1" of the crust, and the flavor of the pizza was just okay. We may visit Soulshine for atmosphere, but not for the pizza.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.