Whenever a restaurant puts their product in the name of the establishment, I expect it to be top notch. For example, everyone goes to Dunkin Donuts for the coffee, not so much the donuts. In the case of Anthony's Cheesecake, you'll go there for the cheesecake and end up walking out with an assortment of pastries after eating one of the best homemade meals (lunch or dinner) you've had in a long time.
The cheesecake is one of the best I ever had the pleasure of tasting. Anthony's cheesecakes are extremely creamy and always fresh. And the crust is a buttery bliss. Every time I have one, I have a debate with myself on which was better--the cheesecake or the crust. My favorite is the peanut butter cheesecake, but to be honest with you, it only outranks the others by a narrow margin because they are all that good.
Another favorite of mine is the apple turnovers. They are huge in size and taste remarkable. The pastry itself is super light and the proportion of apple filling is perfect every time.
Anthony's also does breakfast, lunch and dinner (Thu night only). I strongly suggest following Anthony on Instagram or Facebook to see these amazing culinary creations that he comes up with each day. If this place ever decided to compete on a reality show, I guarantee you that Gordon Ramsay or the Food Network would bow to food that comes out of Anthony's kitchen.
Seriously, you will not leave disappointed after any meal at Anthony's. He serves high-end, NYC-type food at Jersey prices.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.