We stayed at the Raritan Inn during our wedding several years ago and we returned for a reunion. It was a truly wonderful experience. The owners were knowledgeable, helpful, and very pleasant to talk to. The food was very good. They took special care with our dietary needs and prepared a lovely breakfast at our desired time. The aesthetics of the Inn are just lovely - warm, inviting, with excellent detail paid to the restoration of the old Victorian home.
I would highly recommend staying here. We did stay in the largest of the rooms - and it was worth it.