I've been meaning to eat here for about a year, but was hesitant because of the mixed reviews I was hearing, especially from a person who has the same taste buds as me. One night my husband wanted to treat a few family members to a pizza dinner for my daughters birthday, but we wanted a restaurant-type atmosphere. I suggested we try Nicky's. We ordered Fried Calamari and Buffalo Wings for an appetizer, and they were both spectacular! Then, we ordered four different types of pizza - Grandma, Firehouse, White, and Margherita. My favorite was the White and Firehouse, and everyone else loved the Margherita and Firehouse. The service was professional and courteous. Definitely ignore the reviews and try this place out for yourself!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.