You probably wouldn't expect heavenly homemade pies to be sold in the same place you would rent water skis. Sold in a little wooden shack in front of the boat livery, Mary Jane's pies will not disappoint. They are filled with real fresh fruit, (not that sickeningly sweet, jelly-donut-quality mess you'll find in pies of a lesser quality), and the crust is buttery perfection. Go early because quantities are limited, and you won't want to miss the blueberry pie. I have enjoyed Mary Jane's pies on three trips to the Adirondacks, as recently as August 2013 and as long ago as the early 2000s, and each time they are just as good as I remembered them. Don't let the $16 price tag scare you away. Allow yourself to splurge on the blueberry pie; it's worth every penny!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.