I tried Beyond Philly on 9/29 after reading about it's opening on Sayville Patch. A cute retro interior in a house like attached commons in Blue Point on Montauk Hwy. I had a Arn's favorite Cheese Steak off of the menu to go. Fresh sliced ribeye steak grilled flat top with grilled onions,peppers,pepper jack cheese,horseradish mayo, lea&perrins, and I added lettuce and tomatoes. All on a 12" tender hero roll for $8.99. It is the best cheese steak I have had,period. Plenty of meat, all of the other ingredients were in proportion so that one flavor did not overwhelm another. Looked like enough for 2 people but it was so good I ate it all myself! Plenty to choose from on the menu with both beef and chicken, burgers, dogs, kielbasa. Hand cut and tornado fries all looked great. Check it out. Good eats!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.