We arrived about 4:40 pm, had just gotten my grandmother into her wheelchair, and we were greeted in the parking lot by our waitress. She began by apologizing that they were closed for the evening for a private party. My father expressed his sorrow since we flew into NY today and we were looking forward to trying their restaurant. Then she went in and came back out and invited us in. I am so glad she did! This small, family-owned/operated restaurant is worth the price. Loved my meal. The salad, parmesan-crusted bread, Eggplant Napoleon, and carrot cake were exceptional. The portions were robust and our waitress did a great job wrapping up leftovers and was very pleasant when we asked to split the dessert. The eggplant dish was one of the best I've had. All family members enjoyed their meals. I highly recommend Casatina's. We finished before the private party. Thank you for letting us in!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.