Ok. Comparisons to NYC style pizza are exaggerated. This pizza does not taste like NY style (mozzarella is not salty enough, crust is not crispy enough, sauce is not tangy enough) so go to the Pizza Stop downtown if you want authentic NYC style pizza ....but...this pizza is good in its own right. I especially enjoy going there with the family or friends, getting a pie or two, getting a pitcher of soda and eating at their tables. There's something very homey/suburban about the experience; it has become somewhat of a Fairport icon.
Note : They don't sell slices (another nyc difference) and often, the phone line is busy for 10-20 minutes when ordering.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.