After a long search on Tripadvisor for a restaurant with consistent reviews, we finally chose Port's Café and it was an excellent choice. Located right across the street from Senaca Lake, the restaurant is modestly decorated with both indoor and outdoor seating. Our server Erica was extremely knowledgeable and an experienced staff person who assisted us in choosing wines that perfectly complimented our meal. The food here is amazing. The list of specials is what you want to order from. I had a Chilean Sea Bass done in a coconut lime sauce that was fresh and delicious and my boyfriend had a steak that was the best he's had anywhere we've traveled. It was cooked perfectly and the quality of the meat was exceptional. I cannot say enough good things about this restaurant and about the service. Our hats off to the incredible chef as well! In season, I suspect reservations are an absolute must. We went on a weeknight in July and the restaurant was moderately full. If you are staying in Geneva, drive here to dine. If you are staying in Penn Yan, drive here to dine. If you are within a 30 minute drive, really try this place because it is fabulous.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.