It's not a restaurant, it's a place to buy goods. We left with smoked salmon, trout, and honey. We had the smoked trout appetizer @ the Inn at Starlight Lake - so large and delicious - & were told that it came from nearby. The next day my husband went into Hancock NY and asked at a fishing store about where it might have come from. He was given directions and told of the "character" Ray that we'd meet. Have a cooler with you as you need to keep the meats cold. There's a dollar store in Hancock where you could buy one if you don't have anything with you.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.