I've been to Andy's twice now. The first time was manageable, this time was the dagger in the heart for us though. My wife and I decided to grab breakfast because there's not much in the way of options for Highland Falls and we didn't want to drive to Fiddlesticks in Cornwall since we were hungry. We went in the second of two entrances, which visibly upset the waitress. She tossed us two menus and came back minutes later for our order. Attitude and all.
My wife ordered chocolate chip pancakes; which she found to be bland and disinteresting. I ordered the standard eggs/meat/potatoes/toast breakfast. The home fries were not good and needed seasoning very badly. An extra minute or two on the grill wouldn't have hurt either. The breakfast meat was thin and I passed on the sausage. Eggs were cooked well; which is why I didn't give only 1 star. The restaurant itself was extremely dirty and I'm led to believe that they don't have an ice machine, so don't expect ice in your drinks. The waitress brought my wife and other tables' drinks by holding the rim of the glass (major health code no-no). My coffee was refilled once and was burnt.
Overall, very disappointing. This is a classic eatery in a small town with small town politics and a very loyal local customer base which likely keeps it floating (with the one-time transient visitor population to boot). We won't be back and I wouldn't recommend it. Try Fiddlesticks or just settle with McDonalds.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.