You can't go wrong with this motel. the room was very clean albeit basic, the bed comfortable and best of all, the price was right. We paid $65+tax for a weekend night, while the least expensive motel in nearby New Paltz would go for over $100. I doubt we'd have gotten a better room there.
Remember, this is a roadside motel, so don't look for any special amenities. You get towels and bar soap, so bring your own toiletries. You need to run the hot water for a minute or two before you enter the shower, but it eventually heats up. Also, we stayed at the front row of rooms which were close to the road (mostly silent at night, some traffic in the morning), so if there are rooms available in the back row (rooms 7-12) try to get one of those.