We ended up going here after the hotel we originally planned to go to was full. It was a bit difficult to make a reservation since they have no online booking, but in most cases, it should be fine to show up without a reservation if you aren't picky about getting a lake view. It's an older motel, but very well maintained and clean. Furnishings are rustic and real wood. They let us use the pool and boats even after we had checked out.
Highly recommend the bakery / breakfast /lunch place across the street, their sourdough bread is divine, and you MUST try the paysan eggs!More