To start off with I ordered Surf & Turf. The Lobster came out DEAD. And what I mean by that is It Fell apart it was Brown and It Smelled BAD! While I understand everyone in a while you get a Not so good meal. This was Disgusting. Then to top it off the Manager comes to my table and start Arguing with me about the Dead Lobster. I asked how can your Chef Server this inedible food. I was told I have to pay for the Dead Lobster. My Wife Lobster was Fine. I told the I want one like That!!! I asked for the check, Paid and walked out. This was about 2 years ago Have not been back since. Save your Money go to Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.