As a student at New Paltz in the 70's to my recent visits, this is the quintessential New Paltz hang out. When I was going to school, the highlight for P&G's were two things. $1 pitchers of beer, don't know what kind, nor did I care as it did the job, and the most amazing chili I had ever had.
35 years later, I still come back for the best chili and although the beers have rose in price, the combination of the two takes me back in time. P&G's has an entire new menu the last few years, and although Chili with a sweet buttered role is still on the menu, their burgers are out of this world delicious. Zuchini fries are wonderful, along with most everything that I or my family or friends have ordered.
It's truly a deja vu feeling to close my eyes when I visit this place like I did a few weeks ago, and it's like time stood still. Although they have expanded the rooms, and the menu, they have not lost the charm that has made this place a great memory of my past.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.