My parents had their first date here. My sister and her husband had their first kiss here. Any visit to New Paltz calls for a visit to P&Gs, but as I get older, it's lunch I enjoy there most rather than the nightly bar scene. My biggest complaint continues to be that the "hard roll" the menu promises is actually a soft kaiser roll. Excellent french onion soup and chili, good varied menu. The windowed area in the back is especially nice at lunch time. If you're not from New Paltz, went to college there, or are otherwise unaffiliated with the town, you might not think much of the place. The food is decent and filling but don't expect a foodie paradise--that's not what they're selling. Wait staff is pleasant and accommodating.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.