We enjoyed our dinner at this small gem of a restaurant. After going around in circles locating it in on a rainy, dark night, we were delighted to have found it on a main street, no more than a 10 minute walk from our hotel on the other side of Oia.
We had the opportunity to try some interesting things on the menu, including a smoked sheep appetizer and fava bean and onion stew. But everything we ordered had good ingredients and was seasoned just right. This was the most "foodie" place we encountered during our 10 days in Greece.
Also nice was a mix of tourists and local people. We made the acquaintance of a friendly group at the table next to us. The following day we saw them working at a cafe and realized they came to Melitini the evening before after they finished work at the cafe.