We've been dining @ the Island Mermaid since the early 90's. The menu has evolved over the years to include many delicious seafood, pasta and vegetarian dishes. The presentation is always top notch. The ambiance is perfect; a beachy vibe, views of the bay, pretty cocktails. Plenty of options on the kids menu. There are a lot of reviews here, so I'll cut to the chase: ORDER the CALAMARI. It is not to be missed. Even people who have never liked or tasted calamari enjoy this stuff. It is very lightly breaded, über tender (never chewy), perfectly seasoned with a mild kick, and the tomato dipping sauce is lovely. We've sampled calamari all over the world and have found none that compare. Really. We may keep trying, but there is little hope for the others. ; ) Scott (owner) is always on hand to ensure his guests are happy and enjoying themselves. Make a reservation for dinner and watch the sun set over the Great South Bay. Mermaid=Summer.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.