We originally had planned to stay 3 nights but changed to 2 nights a few weeks ahead of our stay. We specifically requested and were confirmed Railroad room which had a separate entrance, tv for the kids and a bathtub. The day before a confirmation was sent for 2 night in Melissa's Sweet. When we asked why we had been switched we were told we were informed of this when we switched rooms. Clearly this was not the case as all our correspondence had been by email and there was not mention of this. We surmized the owners had someone that wanted the Railroad room and also wanted the kitchen which was an optional cost add on for the room which we had not taken. We probably would have been OK with this had we been asked to make the change, but to do this on their own didn't go over well. Especially since our children did not want to use the shower.
The room and house were clean. Single beds were more firm than the queen beds which had the "roll to the middle" thing going on.
Our room rate was noted on the website as $125/night. We were told the rate was actually $150/night because they had yet to update the website.
Continental breakfast consisted everything you could buy at a grocery store. Thomas english muffins, Entenmman doughnuts, Quaker oats, boxed cereals, Folgers coffee, hardboiled (cold) eggs, etc. The point here being there were none of the those special breakfast items you would see at a bed and breakfast.
We saw Bruce briefly each morning to simply check in on whether there was enough coffee in the pot.
The location (just south of Roxbury) is a bit remote if you are looking to spend any time in and around Woodstock or the mountains of Hunter and Windham.
Overall it was a decent stay, but it lacked that special feeling we've experienced while staying at other bed and breakfasts. It felt a bit more like a hostel than a bed and breakfast. That may sound harsh, but we just didn't leave feeling like "We can't wait to come back here again some time again" that we often find ourselves saying.
- Official Description (provided by the hotel):
- Built in 1860, Scudder Hill House is an historical farmhouse that sits on 5 acres of pine, fruit, and maple trees, just across the road from the serenity of Lake Wawaka. Located within a 6 mile radius of skiing, mountain biking, parks, and water recreation, you can enjoy the beauty of outdoors close to the comforts of home with a touch of old world charm. Decorated in antiques and rustic elegance, Scudder Hill House is comfortable, uncluttered, and simple. With windows that go from floor to ceiling, private baths in all quarters, quality beds, and large floor plans, our accommodations offer a spaciousness and comfort we feel is the best value for your money in this area. At Scudder Hill House, wake up to the smell of fresh coffee and start your day off with a hot breakfast and home made baked goods from muffins to coffee cakes all made from scratch by Bruce, served in the Breakfast Room. Here, our guests have 24-hour access to books, coffee, tea, hot chocolate, college-size fridge, and internet service. Then adventure out and take advantage of our nearby activities and attractions. From out front door, walk across the street and jog 3 to 4 miles, bicycle or kayak and canoe on Lake Wawaka. Our guests have confirmed that we have created a cozy, warm, and charming environment that feels like home. We hope you'll think so too. ... more less
- Also Known As:
- Scudder Hill House Bed & Breakfast Roxbury, Catskill Region, New York