My husband and I just had ice cream and a shake at the counter, but we found it to be the kind of place we would like to return to the next time we are on Shelter Island. When I enquired about an egg cream, the waitress whipped one up so I could have a taste, no charge. It was that kind of easy feeling you get when you're in your own neighborhood. There were a lot of people there, and we got the sense that it was a favorite with the locals. Nice feeling to have the locals' stamp of approval, after having been to so many other spots on the island where service meant keeping people at arms-length.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.