We love A Lure. Beautiful location on the water. Great food with nice local beers on tap and Long Island wine selection. Have a drink at the bar, but DON'T eat at the bar if you want a knowledgeable server. Opt for a table with a server that actually knows the menu. We ordered oysters and wanted to make sure cocktail sauce came with it and were told "oh yes everything comes with it". No cocktail sauce upon arrival. Then ordered the macadamia nut crusted flounder sandwich and there was no sauce or dressing. When I asked if it came with a remoulade, she said "oh no I don't think so". It was difficult to eat without any sauce and the bread was over toasted-overall dry. I asked for some mayo, which they brought. Then when we got home I looked at the menu and saw "remoulade" clear as day, to accompany the fried fish sandwich. I never complain about a meal. Some are good, some are not. But when you have someone working for you that is not informed, especially a place with Tom Schaudel's name on it, when so much thought goes into his menu, I would imagine he would be less than impressed.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.